Asphalt vs. Metal Roofing: What’s Best for Your Peoria Home?

Drive through the neighborhoods of Morton, Washington, or East Peoria, and you will notice a growing trend: shiny, sleek metal roofs are popping up everywhere.

For decades, asphalt shingles were the only real option for residential homes in Central Illinois. But today, homeowners are increasingly choosing metal. Is it just a style choice, or is there a practical reason to make the switch?

At Paws Roofing Contractors, we install both systems extensively. Here is an honest comparison of how they stack up against our tough Midwest climate.

1. Durability: Fighting the Illinois Hail

Our region is no stranger to severe weather. From spring hail storms to 60mph wind gusts, your roof takes a beating.

• Asphalt Shingles: Modern architectural shingles are durable, but they have a lifespan. Heavy hail can knock the granules off, exposing the asphalt to the sun and leading to premature aging. A typical asphalt roof in Peoria lasts 20-25 years.
• Metal Roofing: A high-quality steel roof (especially standing seam) is incredibly impact-resistant. It doesn’t crack, warp, or curl. While a massive hailstone might leave a cosmetic dent, it rarely compromises the waterproofing. A metal roof can easily last 50-70 years.

2. Winter Performance: The Snow Factor

This is where metal truly shines in the Midwest.

Asphalt shingles have a rough, gritty texture. This friction holds snow in place. While this acts as extra insulation, it also allows heavy snow loads to accumulate, increasing the risk of structural stress and ice dams (where melted snow refreezes at the gutters).

Metal roofs are slick. When the sun hits the metal, it warms up quickly, causing the snow to slide right off. This self-cleaning ability takes a massive weight load off your home’s structure and virtually eliminates the risk of ice dams forming at the eaves.

3. The Cost Equation: Upfront vs. Long-Term

The biggest barrier to metal roofing is the price tag.

• The Investment: A metal roof will typically cost 2 to 3 times more upfront than an asphalt shingle roof.
• The ROI: However, because it lasts three times longer, the “cost per year” is often lower. If you plan to stay in your home for decades—or if you want to increase its resale value significantly—metal is the smarter financial play.
• Insurance Discounts: Many insurance carriers offer discounts for Class 4 impact-resistant metal roofs, which can offset the cost over time.

4. Aesthetics and Curb Appeal

Metal isn’t just for barns anymore. Modern residential metal roofing comes in a variety of colors (from matte black to charcoal gray) and styles. It offers a clean, modern look that pairs beautifully with brick or vinyl siding.

However, asphalt shingles offer a classic, traditional look that some homeowners prefer, especially in historic neighborhoods in Peoria Heights.

The Verdict?

If you are looking for the most affordable solution to protect your home for the next 20 years, Architectural Asphalt Shingles are still the king of value.

But if you want “the last roof you will ever buy” and want to stop worrying about ice dams and hail damage, Metal Roofing is the superior choice.

Not sure which is right for your budget? Call Paws Roofing. We can provide you with a side-by-side quote for both materials so you can make an informed decision.

---